Of course John Cleeese’s ‘Don’t mention the war’ is regarded as classic comedy …
… but when it comes to the Treaty of Waitangi, there are other, not nearly so satirical calls to avoid discussing contentious topics.
Indeed, there are attempts to continually dismiss calls for redress — of genuine, documented, historic injustices (including large scale land theft) some enabled by racist government policies and actions over generations. Some contemptible ‘commentators’ characterise any Waitangi claims as coming from sub-humans looking for handouts from a gravy train.
In my opinion, the negotiations to settle Treaty of Waitangi claims that have succeeded (as some unquestionably have) have resulted from the exercise of courage and goodwill — under fire sometimes, as we discussed relating to Doug Graham. The willingness of Maori to accept Crown apologies and, in some cases, merely symbolic settlement of grievances has been striking. Forgiveness always is.
But of course, none of that stops the heckling.
Is the system of monetary or asset-based redress imperfect? Yes. And it’s also given to ego-based macho ‘negotiation’ and ‘chiseling’ tactics like wincing, false bottom lines, the reluctant manager, and subject to other vagaries of personality. But it’s start.
It seems to me progress means ignoring racist rednecks with their prejudice and their offensive calls for a ‘brown out’ (yuk) or their shallow slogans and tropes like ‘look forward, not backward’.
Yeah, it’s easy to say that when you’re holding the stolen treasure.
– P
Thanks, Peter. I’d love to hear more on the Taranaki apology you link to via “over generations”. Any chance?
HI Graeme,
That apology was delivered by John Key … it was to Taranaki iwi in Wellington.
See: http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10587766
I don’t know the state of the actual Taranaki negotiations, if any.
– P
Sorry, I thought you meant since then. Has there been no progress since 2009?
One wonders what some could make of this …
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/lifestyle/news/article.cfm?c_id=6&objectid=142690
Stolen Treasure … or maybe stolen generations, lives, right to procreate etc ….
Smacks of genocide to me.
What moves have been made by the mainland Iwi to redress the balance to the disposessed … or do they think it all died with Mr Tommy Solomon.
I once heard a Kuia from North Island Maori say on TV … “that was just the traditional way ..” Referring to genocide and cutting off the bloodline of an enslaved people.
All that was missing was black uniforms, German Shepherds and trains …
The noble – often turn out to be the perpetrators of things much worse than they accuse others of – or am i perhaps mistaken.
Te Whiti o Rongomai would never have allowed or condoned such a thing … but it happened and it was culturally acceptable …
So what in this nation do we perhaps have to look forward to under tino rangatiratanga and the treaty fatcats military-industrial combine … more of the same … under a system of cultural entitlement.
What does a white guy have as a stake in this Peter .. and i presume you are 100% pakeha … with a surname like Aranyi which sounds Eastern European – why are you so concerned.