Last week I wrote to the local Howick & Pakuranga Times about a long-running local issue of importance to me and my family. I was intrigued by some of the deletions and alterations in the resulting published Letter to the editor.
See what you think:
My family and I fully support the moves to rebuild the whare in the Garden of Memories.As a community may we, at long last, bring an end to the undignified and, by all appearances, racist opposition to the reinstatement of this community asset in Emilia Maud Nixon’s garden? Surely we can Can we celebrate her bi-cultural vision? Surely.The opposition to Maori culture in our suburb, and the tactics adopted by a handful of local politicians — fighting the rebuilding of the whare — shows they’re out of touch. Of course they deny it’s racism, but [L]ike others, I have been appalled at what I believe are the provocative, offensive and sometimes misleading statements issued … and actions they have taken.Men and women to whom we look for leadership have let us down. Their delaying tactics and subversive legal machinations have cost us dearly as a community. Their misguided fixation and battle against a shadowy hallucination of a ‘full-blown marae’ in our back yard brings shame on Howick’s the name of Howick.The campaign to suppress Maori culture at the gardens in Uxbridge Road is an embarrassment. (Even more so a delusional ‘declaration of independence’ over the issue.)We all look like racists as a result.
Peter Aranyi, Howick
Interesting, huh? I have no real complaints. It’s their paper, and the editor (rightly) has the last say about what appears in it — good on them for publishing the letter and the ongoing ‘debate’.
It’s illuminating to see what comments are, apparently, beyond the pale for that Letters to the editor forum.
If there was another word for racism that didn’t sound like racism then I think you would have been okay.
“If there was another word for racism that didn’t sound like racism…”
Bigotry? Prejudice? Xenophobia? Racially intolerant? … Paternalistic? Colonialist? Invaders? White supremacists? Fascist?
JT you might be interested in reading Bruce Sheppard’s signing off blog post which includes this:
and this:
http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/blogs/stirring-the-pot/4249073/Its-a-wrap#
Actually, I’ll link to the blog as a post. It is a little long-winded, but he makes some very good points, it is heart-felt… oh, and I agree with a lot of what he says – P
Peter,
I guess what I was trying to say is that the word racism is still racism regardless of which euphemistic phrase or word is used to soften it. The editor of the Howick & Pakuranga Times was simply attempting to couch Truth by removing your use of the word.
But Truth is not elusive for long. So, edit as the Howick & Pakuranga Times will – if what you write is true — then a little cut-and-paste by the Howick & Pakuranga Times will change nothing.
Truth finds a way…
Thanks for your comment and encouragement JT.
If the publication of my (edited) letter keeps the debate going with some illumination of my and other Howick residents’ views of our civic ‘leaders’ and their behaviour, well, good.
In the vacuum, It seems to me, a base and fearful prejudice rules.
So speak up for values, we must. -P
Peter,
I read the full article at the “Times online” by Chris Harrowell, and I think that the subject is a complicated one. There is a history here that has not been articulated. I’d like to know a little more. What is this Garden of Memories? Why is it important to some? And why is it not important to others? What’s the real story here?
Yes, there’s a bit of history all right. Some of it most unedifying, let me tell you.
I’ll put together a background for you (from my point of view) … – P
That would be great. Keep in mind, neutrality might be a better stance. But either way, I’m looking forward to it.
Cheers JT. Almost done.
I’m trying to keep any ‘heat’ out of it… 🙂 P
Well, unnecessary heat.
Here you go JT…
http://www.thepaepae.com/why-do-you-think-we-call-it-a-struggle/9595/
[…] referred earlier this week in ‘Words that may not be spoken‘ to what I see as a subversive, long-running and concerted political campaign which aims to […]